The rise of Airbnb and similar short-term rental (STR) platforms has sparked a significant debate over their impact on housing affordability. Urban centers worldwide face escalating rental prices and a shrinking pool of affordable housing. Consequently, these platforms face increasing scrutiny for their role in this crisis.
Is Airbnb Reducing Long-Term Housing?
Critics argue that Airbnb’s business model, which turns residential properties into lucrative short-term rentals, reduces available long-term housing and drives up rent prices.
Housing Affordability Is More Complex
In contrast, analyses suggest that housing affordability is more complex and intertwined with government policies, market dynamics, and broader economic trends.
Understanding all of these contributors becomes crucial to addressing the problem amid these escalating challenges. It calls for thoughtful solutions that go beyond supply-and-demand economics.
Airbnb Has Undoubtedly Reshaped Property Markets
The expansion of Airbnb and similar STR platforms has notably reshaped property markets. In many cities, the surge in short-term rentals correlates with increased housing costs and dwindling affordable options.
Using Regulation to Curb the Problem
A recent report from the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) highlights that many cities nationwide have placed restrictions on STRs.
These regulatory interventions often resonate positively with locals’ concerns about soaring housing costs, unions, and progressive media outlets. However, the review calls out governments for merely using STRs as a scapegoat to distract from their own policy failures.
Short-Term Rentals Numbers Ballooning
Opinions on this matter are far from unanimous. British Columbia’s Premier David Eby recently introduced legislation to rein in short-term rentals and deliver more homes for people. “Anyone who’s looking for an affordable place to live knows how hard it is, and short-term rentals are making it even more challenging. The number of short-term rentals in B.C. has ballooned in recent years, removing thousands of long-term homes from the market.”
But There Are Other Factors at Play
The AEI analysis suggests that the number of properties converted to STRs represents only a minor fraction of the total housing market. It indicates that other factors may substantially drive up housing costs. Specifically, government-induced distortions are the real reasons behind affordability issues.
Driving Hotel Room Scarcity and Cost Escalation
Policies have resulted in limited hotel room availability, along with zoning and land use regulations that contribute to both scarcity and increased costs. Additionally, factors such as low-interest rates, which stimulate demand, have been absorbed into the market, leading to further escalation of prices.
A Longstanding Issues: Supply, Demand, and Wages
The challenge of housing affordability is a longstanding issue, with its roots extending far beyond the advent of Airbnb. This complex problem has been shaped by various factors over decades, with recent trends further highlighting the quantitative extent of the crisis.
The Fed Reserve’s Insight
Data from the Federal Reserve sheds light on the severity of this issue. In the past six years, the U.S. housing market has experienced a dramatic reduction in active housing listings and a significant surge in median home sale prices.
Plummeting Listings and Rising Prices
Listings have plummeted by nearly 50%, dropping from around 1.5 million in 2016 to less than 700,000 by the end of 2022. Concurrently, the median house price has witnessed an almost 55% escalation, soaring from $311,000 to a peak of $480,000. This increase represents an average yearly rise of 9%. Starkly outpacing the modest 5% annual growth in the preceding two decades.
Outpacing Wage Growth
This rapid increase in housing prices is even more striking when compared to wage growth. Over the last 25 years, wage growth has averaged around 3.7%, as per Federal Reserve data. This discrepancy between housing price escalation and wage increases underscores the growing affordability challenge for the average American.
Historical Trends Prior to Airbnb
These historical trends in the housing market emphasize the depth and complexity of the affordability crisis. While STR platforms may contribute to this issue, the fundamental problem of housing affordability is rooted in broader economic and market changes over time.
Government Intervention and Distortions
The AEI report alleges government regulations in major urban areas have significantly influenced the housing market, often leading to unexpected outcomes.
Government Policies Have Driven STR Demand
Stringent policies, such as the prohibition of youth hostels and strict rules for hotel development, have created a shortage of hotel rooms. This scarcity has inadvertently boosted the demand for STRs.
Limited Hotel Room Availability = Increased STR Demand
In New York City, restrictive policies and influences from groups like the Hotel Trades Council have decreased hotel room availability and increased reliance on STRs as alternative accommodations.
STRs a Feasible Option
In Hawaii, the scarcity of hotel rooms has rendered STRs a more feasible option than traditional long-term rentals. Data indicates that many STRs are sporadically booked and primarily serve as owner-occupied residences.
Government Decisions Causing Market Imbalance
These instances reflect a broader pattern of governmental decisions causing market imbalances. Zoning and land use regulations have significantly contributed to making housing unaffordable.
California’s Golden Price-To-Income Ratio
In California, for example, the price-to-income ratio for housing has consistently been well above the national average for years.
Airbnb’s Impact Is Modest
Despite the spotlight on STRs in the housing affordability debate, their actual effect on housing costs appears to be modest, with estimates suggesting an impact of about 3 to 5%.
The fundamental issue is rooted in supply-side limitations, where policies that restrict land use and favor single-family homes have intensified housing scarcity.
Building Not Banning
The solution to high housing costs and the popularity of STRs lies in facilitating more housing and hotel construction. This approach involves removing bureaucratic barriers to all forms of housing construction.
Lessons From States With Light-Touch Density Legislation
States like California, Washington, Montana, and Oregon, which have passed light-touch density legislation, illustrate the potential benefits of deregulating land use.
Upon passing a bill creating a voluntary, streamlined process for cities to zone for missing middle multi-unit housing, California State Senator Scott Wiener noted, “Severe housing shortage requires many strategies, and making it easier and faster for cities to zone for multi-unit housing is a critical piece of the puzzle.
Creating Opportunity for Private-Sector Housing Construction
These initiatives can open up opportunities for more private-sector housing construction. This approach will address the core issue of supply scarcity that drives both housing costs and the STR market.
Biden’s New 401(k) Rule: Employers Frustrated as Retirement Planning Responsibilities Shift
The latest Biden administration rule on 401(k) plans is reshaping how employers manage retirement plans. It’s a complex scenario requiring a fresh understanding of fiduciary duties and provider relationships. This rule aims to protect employees but also imposes new responsibilities on employers. Biden’s New 401(k) Rule: Employers Frustrated as Retirement Planning Responsibilities Shift
Elon Musk: New Immigration Bill ‘Enables Illegals to Vote’
Elon Musk is calling for prosecutions after the text for a new senate bill on immigration was released. Musk accused the new bill of “enabling illegals to vote.” Elon Musk: New Immigration Bill ‘Enables Illegals to Vote’
Colorado Officials Reject Sanctuary City Status, Warn Against ‘Dangerous Game’
With increasing numbers of migrants arriving in Colorado, public officials have rejected any notion of the state becoming a sanctuary for migrants and asylum seekers. Colorado Officials Reject Sanctuary City Status, Warn Against ‘Dangerous Game’
Disney Challenges DeSantis’ “Don’t Say Gay” Rule With a Hefty Lawsuit
Disney is set to appeal its refusal for a lawsuit against Ron DeSantis, who stripped the company of its rights for disagreeing with the Governor’s views on the teaching of sexual orientation in classrooms. Disney Challenges DeSantis’ “Don’t Say Gay” Rule With a Hefty Lawsuit
Trump on the Attack as 21 Million Americans Flock to Obamacare, Biden Pushes Forward
An unprecedented surge in health plan enrollments has reignited former President Donald Trump’s commitment to dismantling the program should he secure the GOP nomination once again. Trump on the Attack as 21 Million Americans Flock to Obamacare, Biden Pushes Forward
The post Rising Rental Rates: Is Airbnb to Blame? first appeared on From Frugal to Free.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Daniel Krason.
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute or replace professional financial advice.
